President Obama: Cutting Funding to HBCUs Just Isn’t Fair

President Barack Obama is under fire for cutting 85 million dollars in “extra” funding from Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs). According to the Associated Press, President Obama’s education budget included major spending increases, but didn’t include an extra $85 million that black institutions have received annually for the past two years because of a 2007 change to the student loan laws.

Folks are up-in-arms about this slap in the face to HBCUs, suggesting that President Barack Obama should support institutions whose funding has historically been poor in spite of recent high-profile cases of financial mismanagement (Texas Southern University, Morris Brown, Benedict College and Barber-Scotia), scandalous partnerships (Bishop Eddie Long’s “unauthorizedl” NCCU satellite campus operating in Atlanta) and low graduation rates (only 37% graduate within a 6-year academic period).

As someone who taught at an HBCU for 5 years, I understand the peculiar challenges facing HBCUs, which is why the funding is needed. Many of these schools have been operating on shoestring budgets for years and need all of the financial support that they can get.  HBCUs give many students that society has either thrown away or given up on an opportunity to pursue a higher education, which reflects the mission of most of these colleges and universities.  More academic preparatory resources are needed at some HBCUs.

Having said that, many HBCUs are poorly run and it is no longer a secret. Many were built on a church model because missionaries founded the schools.  Because of this, there is a top-down style of management in place, which is not necessarily, the best management model for academic environments, particularly in this day and age.  Consequently, you have a lot of power in the hands of few, so when bad decisions are made, they are far reaching.

As I have written before, HBCUs cannot continue to count on the government for funding. In December of last year, a Georgia State Senator suggested that an HBCU consider joining with a majority institution in order to streamline government costs. Black folks went berserk. We can’t keep asking the government for money, rebuffing attempts at lowering costs, and telling them to mind their business on top it. With endowments that pale in comparison to mainstream universities, HBCU administrators continue to be the highest paid administrators in the country.  Conventional wisdom would suggest that something has to change, and if it doesn’t, funding directly to the universities will decrease and eventually some HBCUs will be forced to merge with mainstream universities in order to survive or fold.

While people are all over President Obama’s case about this, as they should be, they need to look at the bigger picture.  While I do not pretend to be a conspiracy theorist, it is clear to me that there is a plan to drastically reduce the number of HBCUs, if not to eliminate them all together, that seems to be at work. Maybe some HBCUs, located within a 2 mi radius of each other, should consider merging and pooling their resources and power to fight against what is certainly coming?  Maybe we should spend less on show and more on substance? Imagine what could happen if all of the folks that attend Homecoming events, alumni/alumnae functions and sporting events (CIAA and MEAC) took 50% of what they would normally spend during the course of that weekend on entertainment and donated it to their respective institutions? HBCUs probably wouldn’t need this money – they might want it—but they would not necessarily need it because they would have it.

Which leads me squarely back to President Obama who insists on letting it be known that he is not checking for Black folks during his presidential tenure. A few weeks ago he gave “back pay” to Philippino WWII Veterans, which he should have done, in spite of adamantly stating that he would never support reparations for Blacks. Now, he’s cutting funding for HBCUs (and Native American tribal colleges/universities), while increasing funding for Latino Universities, which he should absolutely do – increase money for Latino institutions.  As I have stated before, I do not believe that Blacks should be made to pay because our President looks like us. It is shameful that a Republican president like Bush, recognized the economic need of HBCUs, while President Obama ignores it.  Bush’s interest may have had to do with the fact that some powerful HBCUs are run by staunch Republicans (Presidents and Board Members), but the fact is that the money was made available. Blacks should be treated equally and not made to suffer because of what it might look like to non-blacks.  Shame on President Obama for cutting funds to HBCUs and shame on Obama for continuing to make an example out of us, while allowing others to run amok.

One could argue that HBCUs should have planned ahead, which is true. While the government is giving out billions to rogue corporate CEOs and poorly run corporations and other ethnic institutions, the government could have floated $85 million to HBCUs (there are 101 of them), which collectively graduate the highest number of African-American students in the country.  It might take 6 years, but they’ll graduate (that’s another article).  Since I’m arguing for fairness, I should mention that Obama’s plan did increase the amount of Pell grants and the amount of money to students, overturning a Bush Administration decision that negatively impacted many students, particularly students of color. President Obama wants to give the money directly to the students, while President Bush gave the money directly to the institutions. There should be a happy medium somewhere in there.

Whatever happens, HBCUs need to wake up and smell the proverbial coffee. The writing is on the wall and HBCUs are under fire. If you cannot count on a Black president to look out for you, whom can you count on? Yourself. HBCUs and Black folks need to be proactive and strategically map out a plan to make sure that HBCUs are here to serve the needs of our community now and in the future.


One Response to “President Obama: Cutting Funding to HBCUs Just Isn’t Fair”

  1. renee Says:

    The 85-million dollars was a two year program meant for 2008 and 2009 ONLY. All of the HBCU’s knew this. None of the HBCU’s expected (or should have expected) that funding for 2010 and beyond. The problem lies in what Bush proposed in his 2009 budget. Here is an email as written to the president of (unnamed HBCU) from the Title III Director (at same unnamed HBCU)
    This is regarding BUSH’s 09 budget:
    “Please note the following observations of the 2009 budget that was signed by the president fo the United States for the Department of Education. Please move directly to page 63 for an explanation. ( I have a copy if you’d like to see it) On this page, please note that the funding for last year’s (07)Title III program Part B was $238.1 million. This year’s (08)funding is $238.1 plus an additional $85 million (a.k.a the Congress mandated funding). However, in 2009, note that the Title III HBCU program part B is reduced to $153.1 million and it is recommended that we receive $85 million from the mandatory college cost reduction and access act. First of all, we need to have a better understanding and knowledge of, the College Cost Reduction and Access Act and second we definitely need to know what is going to happen to Title III, Part B funding for the years 2010 and beyond?”

    In other words BUSH reduced HBCU’s discretionary spending by the same amount as the mandated funding and used those mandated funds to make up the difference. That 85 mil was always supposed to be in addition to, not instead of. HBCU’S ‘extra funds’ budget was decreased by BUSH in the 2009 not OBAMA. The provision for ‘extra’ funds is to expire this year.

    It’s shameful that we have so much misinformation being spread about this issue.

    Bottom line is in this the second year of this provision, included in the bill signed by President Bush in 2007, HE SNEAKILY CUT OUT THE FUNDS IN THE FOR 09, so in essence the schools are not even benefiting from the ‘extra’ money this year. They are operating at 2007 (traditional) funding levels!

    I have read the bill. This 85-million dollars (x2) is part of an overall 510-million dollars included in an over 18-BILLION dollar law introduced in Congress in 2007. Blacks, Hispanics, Native Americans and other minorities also benefited from this 510-million dollar provision, but what do ya’ know, it’s only black folks who are crying wah wah wah now that the funds are being phased out AS PLANNED!! (actual bill) port.pdf

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s